AMERICAN DREAM: THREE WOMEN, TEN KIDS AND A NATION'S DRIVE TO END WELFARE
A New York Times reporter chronicles the post-Clinton welfare landscape.

Reviewed By Scott Duke Harris

September/October 2004 Issue

Nothing marked Bill Clinton as a new kind of Democrat more than his campaign pledge to "end welfare as we know it." Both blunt and vague, the promise resonated with a view that the social safety net had become a web that ensnared the underclass, particularly African Americans, in a gloomy pathology of dependency. Too many of the poor, Clinton said, couldn't even dream the American Dream.

American Dream is the melancholy title Jason DeParle of the New York Times chose for his richly researched, beautifully written chronicle of the era that fulfilled Clinton's pledge. Political abstractions are juxtaposed against the personal dramas of three emblematic unwed mothers. By the book's end, the women have 10 children between them, and one, at age 35, is already a grandmother. At first glance, Angie, Jewell, and Opal seem to justify all the criticisms of the welfare system: Each new birth ensures a larger welfare check; they move from Chicago to Milwaukee for higher benefits and cheaper rent; they take jobs without telling the welfare office. Fathers tend to be out of the picture—two are in prison for murder.

But DeParle's intimate reporting reveals that welfare dependence was a symptom, not a cause, of the chaotic happenstance of their lives. On a wrenching day when Angie, in the stirrups preparing to end an unwanted pregnancy, abruptly halts the procedure, it is clear that the prospect of a larger check is the last thing on her mind. These women are survi- vors, scuffling by. When Washington moves to reform welfare, they shrug it off: They'll manage. Two do so, marginally improving their lots. The third, with no net to catch her, finds a bleaker fate.

Welfare reform is recalled as a triumph for Clinton, whose policy benefited from a robust economy. DeParle's judgment: The root cause of troubles in the African American underclass was never welfare. But nobody has figured out how to legislate fatherhood.